Navy Quietly Relieves USS Michael Murphy Commander Mid-Deployment
The U.S. Navy quietly relieved Cmdr. Caitlin Cunningham as commander of USS Michael Murphy, citing a loss of confidence, after the destroyer’s 346-day deployment that included combat against Iran.
Choose Clash Report as a preferred source and see our reporting first in Top Stories.
She had taken command of the Arleigh Burke-class destroyer on Oct. 24, 2025, less than a year before the change.
A Navy spokesperson confirmed the Sept. 27 relief to USNI News, which first reported it as the ship returned to its Pearl Harbor homeport.
Navy Withholds a Reason
The service gave no further explanation beyond a “loss of confidence to command,” a phrase it uses for cases ranging from mishaps on board to personal misconduct, Task & Purpose reported.
Rear Adm. Todd F. Cimicata, commander of Carrier Strike Group 10, relieved Cunningham, a Navy official told The Hill.
The relief came in the tenth month of the cruise, while the ship was still operating in the Middle East.
The Navy did not announce the change in September. The story became public on Nov. 12, the day the destroyer came home, as lawmakers were already criticizing the service over other quiet command removals, including the leadership of USS South Dakota.
Ship Completes Iran Deployment
USS Michael Murphy left Pearl Harbor on Dec. 1, 2025, with the USS Abraham Lincoln Carrier Strike Group and entered the U.S. Central Command area in late January.
A U.S. 3rd Fleet release said the ship took part in Operation Epic Fury, launched Tomahawk cruise missile strikes, helped enforce a naval blockade of Iranian ports and completed 12 contested transits of the Strait of Hormuz.
The destroyer remained in the Middle East after Abraham Lincoln left the region in August and returned on Nov. 12 after 346 days away, about 24 days longer than the carrier.
USS Spruance, another destroyer from the same strike group, returned after 357 days. Task & Purpose said both cruises were among the longest destroyer deployments since World War II.
New Commander Takes Over
Cmdr. David Nicolas, named in the Navy release as the ship’s current commanding officer, praised the crew’s “unmatched grit, professionalism and warfighting excellence.”
Task & Purpose said he has led the destroyer since Cunningham was relieved. Defense One reported that he took command about a month before the homecoming, after plans to send him to a shore instructor post were changed.
The Navy awarded the ship the Presidential Unit Citation for the Iran campaign. Officials have told families that 10- to 11-month deployments will be the new standard for several years, a warning already given to USS George H.W. Bush families.
The Navy has not publicly accused Cunningham of wrongdoing, and she has not commented in published reports.
Kamer Kurunç
Kamer Kurunç is the Team Leader of Clash Report and has led the outlet for four years. He oversees its breaking world news coverage, from the Middle East and the Russia-Ukraine war to defense and global politics. His focus is fast, verified, source-based reporting. Follow him on X at @kamerknc.
Choose Clash Report as a preferred source and see our reporting first in Top Stories.









